The Deciding Factor

VerifiedVerified by the DesignRush team for authenticity and credibility.
Marketing That Makes Up Minds
5155 Financial Way #9, Mason, Ohio 45040, United States
https://decidingfactor.us
The Deciding Factor

The Deciding Factor Overview

Year Founded
2001
Employees
Under 49
Minimal Budget
$1,000 - $10,000
Average Hourly Rate
Inquire
The Deciding Factor is a full-service marketing agency based in Mason, Ohio, with nearly 25 years of experience working with B2B and B2C companies. It specializes in complex products and services that require clear messaging across multiple buyer personas. The agency integrates strategy, creative, technology, and data into one marketing program, reducing the need to manage separate single-channel vendors.

Services include:
  • Brand identity and strategy
  • Search and social advertising
  • Email marketing and automation
  • Website design and development
  • Social media management
  • Content marketing, SEO, GEO, and AEO
  • Marketing technology and analytics

For a B2B packaging manufacturer, TDF helped drive 48% revenue growth from year one to year two, while weekly website traffic grew from fewer than 100 visitors to 600-800 and qualified B2B leads reached approximately $200 per lead.

Its integrated marketing work for travel staffing company TaleMed supported the company's growth from 2017 to 2020 and helped position it ahead of its acquisition by Triage Staffing. TDF also helped a risk management SaaS company build the messaging, content, and demand-generation foundation that supported its acquisition, after which the acquiring company retained TDF to rebrand key assets.

The Deciding Factor fits small and mid-market businesses, as well as divisions of larger companies, that sell technical, regulated, or otherwise complex products and services. It is particularly relevant when multiple audiences influence the buying decision and branding, content, digital advertising, automation, and marketing technology need to work as one system.

The Deciding Factor Portfolio

The Deciding Factor - Highlighting Compassionate Care through Human-Centric Design
B2B
Highlighting Compassionate Care through Human-Centric Design
Health Care
The Deciding Factor - Driving 20% Social Media Growth for a Retail Firm
B2B
Driving 20% Social Media Growth for a Retail Firm
Retail
The Deciding Factor - Building Recruitment and Sales Systems for a Growing Healthcare Staffing Firm
Digital Marketing
Building Recruitment and Sales Systems for a Growing Healthcare Staffing Firm
Health Care
The Deciding Factor - Turning Ad Hoc Marketing Into a Structured Growth Program
B2B Social Media Marketing
Turning Ad Hoc Marketing Into a Structured Growth Program
The Deciding Factor - Driving 48% Revenue Growth for a Packaging Manufacturer
Digital Marketing
Driving 48% Revenue Growth for a Packaging Manufacturer
The Deciding Factor - WebAward-Winning Website for a Cincinnati Therapy Clinic
B2B
WebAward-Winning Website for a Cincinnati Therapy Clinic
Health Care
The Deciding Factor - Attracting Two Main ICP through Clear Content and Navigation
B2B
Attracting Two Main ICP through Clear Content and Navigation
Construction
The Deciding Factor - Rebuilding Branding Trust and Community Engagement for a Nonprofit
B2B
Rebuilding Branding Trust and Community Engagement for a Nonprofit
Nonprofit

Industries

  • Manufacturing
  • Health Care
  • Software & IT Services
  • Consumer Goods
  • Corporate Services
  • Fintech
  • Food and Beverage

Client Types

  • Small Businesses
  • Medium Businesses
Branding Expertise
Branding Expertise
  • Brand Messaging
  • Brand Strategy
CMS Platforms
CMS Platforms
  • WordPress
Digital Marketing Expertise
Digital Marketing Expertise
  • B2B
  • B2B Lead Generation
  • Content Creation
  • Digital Advertising
  • Inbound Marketing
  • Marketing Analytics
  • Marketing Strategy
  • Martech
Email Marketing Expertise
Email Marketing Expertise
  • B2B Email Marketing
  • CRM Emailing
  • Cold Email
  • Email Design
  • Email Marketing Software
  • Newsletter
PPC Expertise
PPC Expertise
  • B2B PPC
  • Bing
  • Google Ads
  • Yahoo
  • YouTube
SEO Expertise
SEO Expertise
  • B2B SEO
  • Local Optimization
  • On-Page Optimization
  • SEO Consulting
Social Media Expertise
Social Media Expertise
  • B2B Social Media Marketing
  • LinkedIn
  • Social Media Consulting
Web Design Expertise
Web Design Expertise
  • B2B
  • Mobile First

The Deciding Factor Clients

ZEISS Industrial Metrology
Pulmonx
Cardiovascular Systems, Inc.
Harris Products Group
Elixir Medical

The Deciding Factor Reviews


Reviews from Google Maps and DesignRush are available on this profile.
All reviews
  • All reviews
  • Google reviews
  • DesignRush reviews
I have worked with many marketing companies through the years, But none of them came close to the service and results we have found at The Deciding Factor.TDF has given us white glove service from the start. They are extremely friendly, professional, collaborative, and they treat our business like it was their own.It’s a pleasure to have a marketing firm who delivers such great results and stays so accessible for all of our needs.They are a true partner, and I would recommend them to everyone. "
Shaun Gilio's Review Sourced from Google
We’ve had a great experience working with The Deciding Factor .The team is responsible, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping our business succeed. They take the time to understand our goals and bring thoughtful ideas and strategy to the table.What we appreciate most is that They feel like an extension of our team rather than just an outside marketing firm.We really love our partnership with The Deciding Factor and highly recommend them to anyone looking for a marketing team that truly cares about their clients and their results. "
Christine Girardi's Review Sourced from Google
The Deciding Factor played a pivotal role in helping us articulate and refine our global strategy. Beyond the planning phase, they were instrumental in the seamless implementation and communication of that strategy to our stakeholders. They took the time to truly understand our industry, effectively integrating themselves as a natural extension of our own team. "
Dave Nangle's Review Sourced from Google
The Deciding Factor really took the time to understand how our sales team works and what we needed to be successful. They helped bring everything together for us. Now, everything feels aligned and intentional. The results speak for themselves this has been the strongest sales performance we've ever seen. "
Project Name: Overall Marketing Strategy
Project Type:
Social Media Marketing
Company size:
50 - 99
Industry:
Packaging and Containers
The Deciding Factor really took the time to understand how our sales team works and what we needed to be successful. They helped bring everything together for us. Now, everything feels aligned and intentional. The results speak for themselves — this has been the strongest sales performance we’ve ever seen. "
Trey DeHart's Review Sourced from Google
Be careful this is a legitimate company, but there is a fake one posing as the real one! I was scammed out of over $1k. They’ll get you by paying you decently at first, then you get roped into having a “negative account balance” and having to pay them more money, with the hope of getting your money back plus a profit. Until the negative balance is an amount you can’t afford. Make sure you can verify the company contacting you and if they mention the Signal app at all, RUN!! "
Nairobi Owens's Review Sourced from Google
Pleasure to work with The Deciding Factor. Very knowledgeable and responsive. They were able to leverage lessons learned from other clients and use them to get our marketing team up and running quickly and help us quickly get processes in place. Highly recommend. "
Project Name: Marketing
Project Type:
Digital Marketing
Company size:
Under 49
Industry:
Information Technology and Services

The Deciding Factor Team Bios

CEO
Karen Meyers Holzer
CEO

Karen Meyers Holzer leads The Deciding Factor as CEO and senior strategist, working across brand strategy, integrated marketing, data, and business growth for companies with complex products and buying journeys.

COO
Karen Vance
COO

Karen Vance serves as COO and senior strategist at The Deciding Factor, working across marketing technology, analytics, channel integration, and strategic planning for complex B2B and B2C marketing programs.