8 Nonprofit Website Design Best Practices That Convert and Retain Donors

Nonprofit website design best practices for earning the first gift and the second, as donor numbers fall for the fifth year running.
8 Nonprofit Website Design Best Practices That Convert and Retain Donors
Rafi Lim
By , Content Editor

Nonprofit website design is now part of fundraising. As donor bases shrink and giving concentrates among fewer, larger donors, the website carries more of the work: earning trust, showing what the money does, pointing each visitor to the right action, and keeping first-time donors close enough to give a second time.

A supporter moves through a nonprofit site in stages, from the first visit and the donation page to the thank-you page and the gift after the first gift. Accessibility applies to every one of those stages, from the Donate button to the form labels and the receipt.

Nonprofit Website Design Best Practices: Key Findings

  • The Fundraising Effectiveness Project's Q2 2026 report found only 11.3% of donors acquired in 2025 had given again by mid-2026, and new retained donors fell 9.5%, the steepest drop of any lifecycle stage.
  • M+R's 2026 Benchmarks Study of 180 nonprofits found 1.6% of website visitors donated in 2025, and mobile users made up 52% of traffic but only 28% of online revenue.
  • The same M+R study found monthly giving made up 27% of online revenue in 2025, while revenue from donor-advised funds rose 44%. 

Nonprofit Websites Have Less Room for Friction After a 3.6% Donor Drop

Nonprofit website best practices are the design and content decisions that help visitors understand a mission, trust the organization, give, and give again. However, the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's Q4 2025 report, built on data from more than 15,000 nonprofits and about 7.8 million donors, found donor counts fell 3.6% in 2025 while dollars raised grew 5%. The decline extends a streak that began in 2021. The money now comes from a narrower base of supporters.

That base keeps concentrating at the top. FEP's Q2 2026 report, which covers about 17,000 organizations and 5.7 million donors, found major and supersize donors gave 76.4% of all dollars through the first half of 2026 while making up 2.9% of donors. A smaller pool of givers leaves less room for confusing navigation, weak donation paths, or buried proof of results.

Retention adds the second pressure. FEP put overall donor retention at 43.3% for 2025, up from 43.1%, which makes post-gift pages, impact updates, recurring giving prompts, and follow-up journeys part of donor growth. FEP changed its methodology starting with its Q1 2026 report, so its 2025 and 2026 figures don't compare directly.

Each of the eight practices in this article fixes a specific point where donors drop off, paired with a nonprofit site that handles it well and the move you can copy to your own.

Practice 

What it fixes

Example

What to copy

1. Paths for every audience 

One homepage for funders, donors, and activists 

Pacific Environment 

Separate giving paths by visitor type, DAFs included 

2. Mission clear in five seconds 

Visitors leaving before they know what you do 

World Central Kitchen, GoFundMe.org

Show the work and say who you are 

3. Low-friction donation page 

Abandoned gifts, worst on mobile 

Doctors Without Borders 

Two gift types, four preset amounts, security answered on the page 

4. Where the money goes 

Donors unsure the gift does anything 

Watsi 

Show cost, amount raised, and amount still needed 

5. Storytelling, one person at a time 

Impact that feels abstract 

Water.org 

A named person, a before and after, their own words 

6. Monthly giving as membership 

A monthly checkbox nobody notices 

charity: water 

Name the program and price each amount in outcomes 

7. A next step after the gift 

Dead-end receipts 

Kiva 

Turn every completed gift into the next action 

8. Accessibility at every step 

Donors who cannot complete the form 

UNICEF USA 

Test the checkout by keyboard and scan before the homepage 

What a Nonprofit Website Should Include, and Who Needs Each Part 

A nonprofit website should include ten elements, and each one answers a question a specific visitor brings to the site. Each element has a person who looks for it and a place that person expects to find it. Funders look for audited financials within two clicks, while first-time visitors look for the mission above the fold.

Element 

Who looks for it 

Where it belongs 

One-sentence mission statement 

Every first-time visitor 

Above the fold on the homepage 

Donate button 

Individual donors 

Main navigation, on every page 

Donation page with a monthly option 

Donors deciding how to give 

One click from any Donate button 

Named monthly giving program 

Prospective monthly donors 

Its own page, linked from the form 

Impact proof with current figures 

First-time donors 

Homepage, program pages, and beside the form 

Annual report, audited financials, and Form 990 

Funders and major donors 

Within two clicks, usually under About 

EIN with DAF and stock giving instructions 

DAF holders and financial advisors 

A Ways to Give page 

Leadership, board, and contact details 

Funders, partners, and press 

About section and footer 

Petition, sign-up, or volunteer form 

Activists and volunteers 

A Get Involved menu item 

Accessibility statement 

Every visitor 

Footer, linked sitewide 

1. Design for Donors, Funders, Decision-Makers, and Activists

Funders, decision-makers, individual donors, monthly prospects, DAF holders, and activists come to a nonprofit site for different things. A site that routes them separately gets each one to the right page faster. 

Roberta Camp-Albert, Business Development Manager at ForeFront Web, says most nonprofit sites treat every visitor the same, with one homepage, one navigation, and one generic button. A site that drives action, she says, "separates people by what they are there to do" and gets them to it fast. 

  • A foundation officer needs financials, program reports, and outcomes data within two clicks. 
  • An individual donor needs an emotional entry point and a fast donation path. 
  • A prospective monthly donor needs to understand what the organization's membership or giving program includes. 
  • Donor-advised fund supporters need grant instructions, while activists look for a petition, campaign update, or sign-up form. 

With clear information architecture, each of those visitors recognizes a path without digging through unrelated content. A site with no visible DAF path gives DAF holders nowhere to go. 

M+R's 2026 Benchmarks found the average DAF gift reached $1,430 in 2025, against $120 for the average direct mail gift, a comparison M+R itself calls unfair for several reasons. The same study found revenue from donor-advised funds rose 44%.

Pacific Environment Gives Clear Paths for Every Supporter

Pacific Environment nonprofit website homepage with a sea turtle hero, a Get Involved button, and a two-sentence mission statement
[Source: Pacific Environment]

ForeFront Web began the Pacific Environment redesign with audience and site research, including analytics, Search Console, content auditing, and competitor analysis.

That research showed what funders, decision-makers, individual donors, and online supporters needed from the site before design work began. Camp-Albert says the team stopped assuming that a funder, a decision-maker, and an individual donor all wanted the same thing when they landed on the site. 

Pacific Environment nonprofit website Explore More Ways to Give page with cards for business sponsorship, DAFs and other giving resources, and estate and legacy giving
[Source: Pacific Environment]

Pacific Environment's Ways to Give page has cards for business sponsorship, DAF and stock gifts, and estate and legacy giving. The donation form offers monthly, one-time, and yearly gifts, with one-time presets from $35 to $1,000 plus an Other field. For your own site, separate giving paths by visitor type, DAFs included.

Pacific Environment nonprofit website donation form offering monthly, one-time, and yearly gifts with preset amounts from $35 to $1,000
[Source: Pacific Environment]

The redesign earned Pacific Environment two 2026 Communicator Awards of Excellence, the program's highest honor, in the General Non-Profit and Website Redesign categories. Excellence winners generally score 90 or above out of 100.

Explore The Top Web Design Companies
Some agencies shown here include sponsored placements
Digital Silk is an agency focused on Creating Superior Digital Experiences for their clients. They create cutting-edge brand strategies, websites...
We're a global group of strategists, designers, and engineers building notable brands and premier digital experiences that captivate users...
Baunfire is a digital agency based in Silicon Valley, delivering elevated corporate websites for leading technology brands, B2B companies, venture...

2. Make the Mission Clear in Five Seconds

A first-time visitor should be able to answer three questions within seconds: What does this organization do, can I trust it, and will my donation make a difference? Your homepage answers them with one strong impact figure, one real story, and a visible donation button.

Within five seconds, Camp-Albert says, a visitor "should understand who you help and what changes because your nonprofit exists." Visitors who need more reassurance should reach financial reports, ratings, program results, and leadership information without digging through several pages.

World Central Kitchen Explains Its Work Before Visitors Scroll

World Central Kitchen nonprofit website homepage leading with a live headline about its wildfire response in Ávila, Spain, and a Donate Now button
[Source: World Central Kitchen]

World Central Kitchen answers the mission question with its current work. The homepage hero carries the latest response, which was a wildfire response in Ávila, Spain, when the screenshot was taken. A first-time visitor sees what the organization does before reading a word of mission copy.

World Central Kitchen nonprofit website map of ongoing and past responses beside a 600 million meals figure
[Source: World Central Kitchen]

The explanation arrives one module later. A response map sits beside a meals count, more than 885 million meals at the time of writing, and a single line describing chef-prepared meals for communities hit by disasters and humanitarian crises. Show your work first, then say who you are.

GoFundMe.org Clarified Its Identity Without Losing the GoFundMe Connection

 GoFundMe.org logo before and after the redesign, from a green wordmark with a sun icon to a light wordmark on navy
[Source: Bilberrry]

GoFundMe.org had a branding challenge that could undermine trust almost immediately. Visitors needed to recognize its connection to GoFundMe.com, but also understand that they were dealing with a separate nonprofit organization.

Bilberrry, a Seattle web design and development agency, helped reshape the nonprofit's brand, messaging, website design, and custom WordPress experience around that distinction.

GoFundMe.org nonprofit website homepage with a Here to Help message and a note stating it is separate from GoFundMe, Inc.
[Source: GoFundMe.org]

The homepage now states the relationship directly. Under the heading "Here to help," a line identifies GoFundMe.org as a separate, independent entity from GoFundMe, Inc. and its fundraising platform and sends anyone starting a personal fundraiser to GoFundMe.com. Organizations facing the same identity problem can compare nonprofit branding agencies that handle brand and site together.

Adam Brazg, CEO of Bilberrry, says the team's job was to remove every point of confusion between the nonprofit and its parent platform, from the logo down to how fundraisers appear on the page. "Donors give when they understand exactly who they're giving to and where the money goes," he says. Say who you are on the homepage, in plain words.

3. Remove Friction From the Donation Flow

A donation page needs clear choices, few fields, visible security, and enough trust signals to keep donors moving. You can build it on a hosted platform such as GoFundMe Pro (formerly Classy), Donorbox, Givebutter, or Bloomerang.

The completion figures show why the page deserves the attention. M+R's 2026 Benchmarks found 11% of desktop users who reached a main donation page completed a gift, against 8% of mobile users and 4% of mobile users at small nonprofits. Desktop gifts averaged $168 and mobile gifts $88.

M+R found 79% of participating nonprofits accepted PayPal, 58% accepted Google Pay, and 57% accepted Apple Pay. Each of those wallets lets a phone user give without typing a card number.

Doctors Without Borders Makes Giving Secure, Flexible, and Easy to Complete

 Doctors Without Borders nonprofit website homepage with a red Donate button in the top navigation
[Source: Doctors Without Borders]

Doctors Without Borders runs its donation page on Classy, now GoFundMe Pro, and keeps the decision small. The form offers two gift types, give once or monthly, and four preset amounts from $25 to $1,000, with an optional dedication and a single Donate button. A thank-you message sits beside the form.

Doctors Without Borders nonprofit website donation page with give-once and monthly options, four preset amounts, and a thank-you message beside the form
[Source: Doctors Without Borders]

Further down, the page's FAQ states that donor information is protected with industry-standard SSL. The page also cites the organization's four-star Charity Navigator rating. Offer two gift types and four preset amounts, and answer the security question on the page itself.

4. Show Donors Where Their Money Goes

Show donors what their gift funds, how the organization uses money, and what proof supports the ask. Project details, cost breakdowns, impact reports, financials, updates, ratings, and transparency seals give them that proof, and first-time donors, who have no history with the organization, need it before they give. 

Place impact proof close to the moment of giving. An annual report reaches the people already committed, while a cost figure next to the Donate button reaches the visitor still deciding.

Watsi Shows Donors the Cost Behind Each Patient’s Care

Watsi nonprofit website homepage with the headline Fund Healthcare for People Around the World and a Donate Now button
[Source: Watsi]

Watsi builds impact proof into the giving experience itself. Each patient has a profile that explains the medical need, the planned treatment, the share already funded, the amount raised, and the amount still needed. Donors see what their money buys before they give.

Watsi nonprofit website patient profiles showing each child's story, percent funded, amount raised, and amount still to go
[Source: Watsi]

Watsi's FAQ states that 100% of General Fund donations support patients. Beside the patient-level detail, the site displays a GuideStar Platinum Seal of Transparency, from the organization now called Candid, and a four-star Charity Navigator rating. Show the cost, the amount raised, and the amount still needed. 

5. Use Storytelling To Move Donors to Give

An impact story gives a donor one person to follow, with a name, a face, and a change the reader can picture. Give every person the same arc: the problem, what the gift paid for, and what changed, told in that person's own words.

Use video to carry the same arc on the homepage and the donation page. Short beneficiary stories, testimonials, and project updates put that evidence where people decide to give, as long as the audio and message stay clear.

Water.org Puts a Face and a Story Behind Every Gift

Water.org nonprofit website homepage with a Donate button in the navigation and a $5 Turns On a Tap banner
[Source: Water.org]

Water.org organizes its impact proof around individual people. Its Stories of Impact page leads with one person at a time, each with a name, a photo, and a short before-and-after arc.

Water.org nonprofit website Stories of Impact page with individual stories of Gecilda, Aucilene, and other women with safe water at home
[Source: Water.org]

Aucilene's story shows the pattern. She lives in a semi-arid part of rural Brazil, where collecting water meant trips to a distant reservoir. The story ends with the cistern she financed through a small loan from a local Water.org partner bank, and with her own account of what changed.

Water.org nonprofit website All Stories page with a featured story and filters by country and topic
[Source: Water.org]

The same structure repeats across profiles, and Gecilda's adds video. Donate sits in the main navigation on every page, and the homepage banner reads "$5 turns on a tap for someone in need," followed by "Donate now." Give each story a named person, a before and after, and their own words.

6. Make Monthly Giving Feel Like Membership

Monthly donors make a longer commitment, and the website should give the program an identity that matches it. A named program, amounts priced in outcomes, and content only members receive turn a recurring charge into something a donor belongs to.

The retention gap explains why the program matters. FEP's Q2 2026 report found donors who gave seven or more times in a year were retained at 90%, compared with 14.4% of one-time donors.

Monthly giving's share of revenue rises with organization size. M+R's 2026 Benchmarks found it made up 22% of online revenue at small nonprofits (under $1 million) and 37% at the largest (over $10 million).

charity: water Turns Monthly Giving Into a Donor Community

 charity: water nonprofit website homepage donation widget with Monthly preselected and amounts from $10 to $100
[Source: charity: water]

charity: water brands its monthly program as The Spring, a community the homepage puts at tens of thousands of supporters. The homepage widget preselects Monthly and prices each amount in people served: $40 a month gives 12 people clean water every year on average.

The Spring’s own page says $20 a month is enough to bring six people, an entire family, clean water each year. Members also get The Journey, a video series made exclusively for The Spring that follows the field work their gifts support.

 charity: water nonprofit website section explaining that private donors fund operations so 100% of public donations fund clean water projects
[Source: charity: water]

The program also leans on a stated 100% model, in which private donors cover operating costs and public donations fund water projects. charity: water shows donors where completed projects are located and shares photos from the field. Name your monthly program and price each amount in outcomes.

7. Design the Next Step After the Gift

Once someone gives, the website should confirm what happened, connect the gift to its result, and start building toward the next interaction. FEP's Q2 2026 report found only 11.3% of donors acquired in 2025 had given again by mid-2026.

Tim Sarrantonio, Chair of the Fundraising Effectiveness Project, says the data cannot show whether a lapsed $25 supporter "still cares and simply never heard from anyone again." He made the point in FEP's Q2 2026 release. Camp-Albert recommends using the thank-you page and email to start building toward the second donation.

The first weeks matter for monthly donors too. M+R's 2026 Benchmarks found 10% of new sustainers stop within two months of setting up a monthly gift, while 71% are still giving after a year.

A dead-end receipt wastes the moment right after the gift. The thank-you page, confirmation email, donor account, and follow-up prompts can point to a funded project update, a share prompt, email sign-up, or a monthly upgrade. Teams without the capacity to run that sequence can bring in nonprofit marketing agencies.

Kiva Turns Repayment Into a Built-In Next Step

 Kiva nonprofit website homepage inviting visitors to lend as little as $25, above loans that are almost funded
[Source: Kiva]

Kiva is a lending platform, so the repeat action is relending. The design principle still applies: every completed transaction leads to another clear action.

Kiva nonprofit website borrower profile for Annet in Uganda showing $125 to go, days remaining, and $25 to $75 lend options
[Source: Kiva]

Supporters choose a specific borrower before lending, then follow repayment activity as funds return to their Kiva account. Kiva states its borrowers repay 96.4% of loans on average. Each repayment becomes the prompt to lend again.

Kiva supports the loop with transparency. Its finance page says "100% of your loans go to local communities," and the site states plainly that lending involves risk of principal loss. Turn every completed gift into the next action.

8. Build Nonprofit Website Accessibility Into Every Step of the Gift

Nonprofit website accessibility applies to every step of the gift: the Donate button, the form labels, the contrast on the impact figures, and the captions on the story videos. A donor who can’t complete the form with a screen reader or a keyboard leaves at the same point a frustrated mobile donor does.

Nonprofit home pages start from a better baseline than most sites and still fail. The WebAIM Million 2026 found home pages it classified as Non-Profit/Charity averaged 43.0 detectable errors, 23.3% fewer than the 56.1 average, and missing form input labels appeared on 51% of all home pages. WebAIM assigned site categories with an AI model (AWS Bedrock), so the category figure is an estimate.

Some nonprofits also face a compliance date. The HHS Section 504 rule requires recipients of HHS funding to meet WCAG 2.1 Level AA by May 11, 2027 if they have 15 or more employees, or by May 10, 2028 if they have fewer.

Those dates are contested. The National Federation of the Blind sued HHS and the Department of Justice in Maryland federal court on May 21, 2026 to vacate the extensions and restore the original deadlines of May 11, 2026 and May 10, 2027. The NFB moved for summary judgment in September 2026, with no ruling as of late October 2026, so if the court restores the original dates, the earlier deadlines apply again.

UNICEF USA Keeps Its Donation Checkout Usable Without a Mouse

UNICEF USA nonprofit website homepage with the Skip to Main Content link visible after one press of the Tab key, above the Donate Now and Give Monthly buttons
[Source: UNICEF]

UNICEF USA raises money in the United States for UNICEF's work with children in crisis, and its Donate buttons open a donation checkout on top of the current page. At the time of writing, DesignRush tested the homepage and that checkout with the open-source axe-core 4.10 engine in a Chromium browser, a keyboard-only pass, and a check at a 320-pixel screen width. 

The first press of the Tab key reveals a Skip to Main Content link, so a keyboard or screen reader user can jump straight past the navigation. The scrolling news ticker under the logo carries a Pause Sliding control for anyone distracted by moving text. At 320 pixels wide, the width of a small phone held upright, the homepage reflowed without sideways scrolling.

UNICEF USA nonprofit website donation checkout with give once and monthly options, preset amounts, an amount field, Google Pay and PayPal buttons, and donor FAQ links
[Source: UNICEF]

The checkout opens in a frame titled Donation Form, and keyboard focus moves into that frame. Every control carries a name a screen reader can announce, from Give Once and Monthly to each preset amount, the amount field, and the Google Pay and PayPal buttons. 

The axe-core scan found no WCAG 2.0, 2.1, or 2.2 Level A or AA violations inside the checkout and passed 25 rules. The form runs on Fundraise Up, which states WCAG 2.2 AA conformance. The scan result matches that claim as far as an automated tool can check. 

The homepage still has gaps. The scan flagged two blocks of small print below the WCAG AA contrast ratio, and the site linked no accessibility statement at the time of testing. Automated checks cover only part of WCAG, so testing with disabled donors who use screen readers is what confirms a form works.

A low-contrast line on the homepage slows a donor down, while an unlabeled payment field stops the gift. That difference is why smaller teams should test the checkout by keyboard and scan it before they work on the homepage.

How to Check Your Donation Platform's Accessibility Statement

If your donation form runs on a hosted platform such as GoFundMe Pro, Givebutter, Bloomerang, or Fundraise Up, the vendor writes the form’s code.

You choose the fields, preset amounts, and colors, but you can’t fix a missing label or a broken keyboard path yourself. That makes the page where the gift happens the one page your team can’t repair, and the vendor’s accessibility statement the main evidence of how that page performs.

Find your vendor’s accessibility statement, note its date and conformance level, and ask for its Accessibility Conformance Report before your next renewal.

Givebutter's statement, last updated October 18, 2022, says it is partially conformant with WCAG 2.1 Level AA. It also says Givebutter's donation forms are not yet fully compatible with screen readers.

Bloomerang's statement, updated April 1, 2026, says it is partially conformant with WCAG 2.2 AA. Bloomerang also offers an annual Accessibility Conformance Report from the auditor QualityLogic.

Fundraise Up states that its Checkout Modal, Campaign Pages, Elements, and Donor Portal conform to WCAG 2.2 AA, verified by independent third-party auditors it does not name. To run the check, find your vendor's statement, note its date and conformance level, and request the conformance report before your next renewal.

Is It Time To Redesign Your Nonprofit Website?

No single issue automatically justifies a nonprofit website redesign. Look at how often problems occur, which visitors they affect, and whether your team can fix them within the current site, and set goals before a redesign starts.

1. Donation rates are falling while traffic remains steady.

M+R's 2026 Benchmarks put the share of visitors who donate at 1.6%. Compare your own rate over time and by traffic source. A sustained decline or repeated abandonment on the donation page can mean visitors are interested but struggling to finish.

2. The donation form creates unnecessary work.

Long forms, required accounts, limited payment options, and confusing error messages give donors more chances to leave. The experience gets less reassuring when the form redirects to a third-party page that looks unrelated to the nonprofit's site.

3. The relationship ends with the receipt.

A basic payment confirmation does little to earn another gift. FEP's Q2 2026 report found only 11.3% of donors acquired in 2025 had given again by mid-2026. First-time donors should receive a clear thank-you, an explanation of what happens next, and a relevant way to stay involved.

4. Visitors cannot find the right way to give.

A single donation page works for one-time gifts, and it leaves out monthly giving, donor-advised funds, workplace giving, and major gifts. Each option needs a clear path and enough information for the donor to proceed. DAF gifts averaged $1,430 in 2025, according to M+R's 2026 Benchmarks.

5. Mobile visitors complete fewer donations.

Mobile brought 52% of nonprofit website traffic in M+R's 2026 Benchmarks but only 28% of online revenue. Check whether the mobile experience has slow pages, small buttons, crowded fields, or payment methods that require too much typing. 

6. Your organization is becoming harder to find online.

M+R found organic search still brought 39% of nonprofit website visits in 2025 but declined over the year, which M+R ties to the spread of AI summaries. M+R says it does not yet know whether the decline will continue. Review whether your program and impact pages still appear for relevant searches and explain the work clearly enough for search engines and AI tools. 

7. Analytics cannot show where donations are lost.

ForeFront Web recommends tracking donation-page views, form starts, payment steps, and completed gifts in GA4. If visitors start the form and abandon it, examine length, error messages, payment options, and mobile usability. If they never reach the form, look at the mission explanation, the impact proof, or the donation call to action.

Redesign, Refresh, or Rebuild?

Websites have a life cycle, and Nicole Sauk, owner of Ventus Design Studio, told DesignRush to plan a redesign about every three to five years, depending on how well the site was built and maintained. Not every issue calls for a full rebuild, the most expensive and disruptive option. Match the scope of work to the problem.

If the problem is...

The fix is usually... 

What it involves

Tired visuals, dated copy, or a weak donate button, but the structure and platform are sound 

A refresh 

Design and content updates and conversion tweaks on your existing system 

Confusing navigation, poor donor journeys, or a high-friction donation flow, but the platform still works 

A partial redesign 

New page templates, reworked navigation, and a rebuilt donation flow on the same CMS 

An outdated or insecure platform, one your team can't maintain, or several deep problems at once 

A full rebuild 

A new platform and architecture, content migration, and fresh integrations 

Start with the smallest change that clears the signals you identified, and reserve a full rebuild for when the platform itself is the constraint or several structural problems overlap. Otherwise, you spend rebuild money on a refresh problem.

Nonprofit Website Best Practices: What To Fix First

These fixes run from the cheapest change to the most expensive. That order differs from the supporter's journey, which starts on the homepage and continues past the first gift. 

  • Start with the donation page on mobile. Mobile brought 52% of traffic but only 28% of online revenue in M+R's 2026 Benchmarks. Cut fields to amount, name, email, and payment, and turn on digital wallets. 
  • Design the first 60 days after a gift before the next appeal. M+R found 10% of new sustainers stop within two months, and FEP found only 11.3% of donors acquired in 2025 gave again by mid-2026. Build the thank-you page and first emails before new campaign pages. 
  • Route visitors by what they came to do. Give funders, donors, DAF holders, and activists their own paths from the homepage. 
  • Show the cost of an outcome next to the ask. Watsi's amount still needed and charity: water's price per family give the donor a reason to finish the form. 
  • Bring in a partner when the platform is the problem. Copy, navigation, and form settings are in-house work, while a platform migration or full rebuild is where an agency earns its fee.

Our team ranks agencies worldwide to help you find a qualified partner. Visit our Agency Directory for the top nonprofit web design companies, as well as: 

  1. Nonprofit Digital Marketing Agencies
  2. Nonprofit Branding Agencies
  3. Nonprofit SEO Companies
  4. Top UI/UX Design Agencies
  5. Top WordPress Web Design Companies

Our design experts also recognize the most innovative and creative projects. Browse the best nonprofit website designs recognized by the DesignRush Design Awards.

👍👎💗🤯

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes a good nonprofit website?

A good nonprofit website tells a visitor who you are and why it matters within seconds, shows proof that gifts produce real results, and leads to a branded, mobile-friendly donation form that asks for as little as possible. It also gives funders, individual donors, DAF holders, and activists their own paths to the page each one needs.

Why do first-time donors not come back, and can a website fix it?

Only 11.3% of the donors who first gave in 2025 had made a second gift by mid-2026, according to FEP's Q2 2026 report. A website helps by designing the post-gift moment: a genuine thank-you and impact confirmation, an easy invitation to give monthly, and on-site impact updates that show the donor exactly what their gift did.

How many fields should a donation form have?

Ask only for what you need to process the gift and send a receipt: amount, name, email, and payment details. Every extra field is another chance to abandon the form. Collect optional details, such as a mailing address, phone number, or how someone heard about you, after the donation or skip them entirely.

Should monthly giving be pre-selected?

Most nonprofits don't preselect it. M+R's 2025 Benchmarks, which cover 2024 data, found that 62% of main donation pages preselected one-time giving and 90% preselected monthly giving.

Defaulting to monthly can frustrate one-time donors if the option isn't clearly labeled and easy to change. A/B test the default with your own audience and let your data decide.

Why is mobile donation conversion usually lower than desktop?

Mobile donors face more friction from small tap targets, long forms, slow page loads, and fiddly typing on a small screen. M+R's 2026 Benchmarks found 11% of desktop users who reached a main donation page completed a gift, against 8% of mobile users. The fixes are practical: shorten the form, enable digital wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay, speed up the page, and make buttons large and obvious.

How much does a nonprofit website redesign cost?

DesignRush's pricing data puts nonprofit website projects at $3,000 to $20,000+, and a simple one-to-five-page site starts around $7,000. Scope sets the final number more than the size of your organization does.

Your price depends on how many unique page templates you need, how much content must be written or migrated, whether the design is custom or built on an existing theme, and which integrations you require, like a donation platform, CRM, multilingual support, accessibility, and analytics. For budgeting detail, see our web design budget guide.

How do we choose a nonprofit web design agency?

Choose an agency that has built donation flows on the platform you use, can show nonprofit work with measurable results, and puts WCAG 2.1 AA conformance in the contract as a deliverable. Ask each finalist how they would route funders, donors, and DAF holders, and compare the answers against your budget.

DesignRush lists nonprofit website design companies with portfolios, minimum budgets, and verified reviews, so you can shortlist by budget band before the first call. Send the same brief to three of them and compare how each one scopes the donation flow.

Latest Web Design Trends
Receive our NewsletterJoin over 70,000 B2B decision-makers growing their brands