Find top content marketing agencies to craft engaging brand stories that drive tangible business outcomes. Select experts from our vetted list of content marketing companies that specialize in copywriting, social media, and SEO.
After carefully considering each agency’s client reviews, pricing, range of content marketing services, portfolios, and industry reputation, we handpicked the finest content marketing companies. Below, you’ll discover what sets each of these agencies apart, as well as our ranking criteria.
The Number 1 Content Marketing Agency as Selected by DesignRush Is:
Notable Clients: Warner Brothers, eBay, Caliber Collision, and more
HigherVisibility produces content marketing that drives profitable business growth through its proprietary Targeted Growth System (TGS). Its steps involve custom strategy development, precise audience targeting, data-driven execution, and continuous optimization. With it, the content marketing company has helped clients increase organic leads by 191% and achieved a 124% return on ad spend. Moreover, it has won multiple awards and recognitions, including the Search Engine Land Awards and the US Agency Awards.
Despite its established reputation, Allied Van Lines fell behind competitors. It struggled with low-quality content, leading to lower site authority, poor search visibility, reduced organic traffic and lead generation, and disavowed quality links.
To resolve these issues, it partnered with HigherVisibility. The content marketing agency used historic data to identify valuable keywords, develop relevant and engaging content, optimize on-page elements, and implement link building and conversion rate optimization (CRO) tactics. As a result, Allied Van Lines increased year-on-year (YoY) organic traffic by 2.6%, month-on-month (MoM) leads by 800%, and YoY organic conversions by 9.4%.
Notable Clients: Nextiva, Casper, TripAdvisor, Norton, Airbnb, and more
Siege Media offers a unique approach to enhancing your website's authority through passive link building. As a collective of creatives, marketers, and SEO experts, Siege Media has generated content valued at approximately $12,387,175 per month in client traffic, which equates to $148,646,100 per year.
Zendesk approached Siege Media with the realization that its outdated content failed to generate desired traffic levels. It needed experts who could implement SEO best practices, conduct comprehensive keyword research, and create high-quality and strategic content to enhance its search engine ranking, drive traffic growth, and increase conversions.
The agency then revamped Zendesk’s existing content, focusing on technical SEO and design optimization. It also implemented a bottom-funnel strategy on their blog and service pages, featuring content that showcased the client’s expertise in software, customer service, and technology. These content pieces effectively combined informational and transactional elements and utilized high-quality imagery and user-friendly charts. The result was a surge in traffic: 37% growth to Zendesk’s blog, $731,924 in overall traffic value growth, 94% growth in organic traffic, and 10,675+ passive links.
Notable Clients: Miner, Stanford University, Rubbermaid Commercial, Canva, Cisco Systems, and more
Brafton's mission is to help businesses succeed through content marketing services and technology solutions worldwide. Its creative and consulting teams write for any industry, from technically complex niches to B2B and B2C brands, utilizing data-led digital content to resonate with the audience and generate results.
The strategy for their client, Quench USA, was to increase brand awareness by enhancing the company’s presence on search. With this in mind, Brafton crafted an SEO strategy that targeted not just consumers but also executives, small-business owners, and office administrators. Using a mix of general terms, such as “hydration facts,” and commercial-intent terms, like “water cooler service for office,” the agency ensured that the website ranked on Page 1 for the right keywords. Consequently, Quench achieved 37 new Page 1 keywords, with 21 being in positions 1 to 5, a $55,377 boost in monthly traffic value, and an increase of 443% in monthly traffic.
Notable Clients: Adobe, Amazon, Asana, Dropbox, eBay, Facebook, Fiverr, and more
Since its establishment in 2009, Column Five has been a leading creative agency specializing in B2B ventures. The agency harnesses the incredible power of storytelling as the ultimate differentiator, transforming ideas into successful campaigns for Fortune 500 companies, startups, and SMEs. It empowers brands to connect with their lifelong customers, foster meaningful relationships, and make conscious decisions that benefit individuals, profitability, and our shared planet.
Dropbox wanted to enhance its Talent Brand by introducing its brand to potential employees, attracting new talent, and engaging with the community. To provide an honest and genuine glimpse into #LifeInsideDropbox, Column Five created a series of videos featuring employees from around the world sharing their career journeys at Dropbox. This series aimed to humanize the brand, generate enthusiasm, and inspire viewers by recounting an authentic view of life within the organization.
Notable Clients: Twenty 20, Nextiva, Harris Teeter, Intuit, and more
Single Grain is a team of passionate professionals who use cutting-edge tools and technology, and personalized marketing strategies to generate leads, drive sales, and foster genuine connections. The agency’s remote-first approach allows them to work with talented creatives regardless of location.
One of their clients, Intuit, a well-known name in tax and personal finance services, recognized an opportunity to provide easy-to-use tools for other business aspects, such as website creation. While Intuit developed and launched the Intuit Website Builder, it needed help to gain traction and visibility in a new and different marketplace dominated by more established competitors. To tackle this challenge, it enlisted the services of Single Grain to create high-quality content and solidify its reputation as a powerful website-building solution.
The firm conducted an in-depth competitive analysis and increased efforts in blogging and social media to engage the existing user community and connect with new users. Within only seven months, the collaboration significantly increased Intuit's visibility in a highly competitive keyword environment across a wide range of common search terms.
Notable Clients: Sodexo, Adobe, Cisco, Salesforce, Autodesk, and more
Tendo is a comprehensive B2B content agency with expertise in crafting, implementing, and optimizing integrated content experiences that drive toward ambitious business objectives. It is a collective of seasoned strategists and creative minds with the knack for transforming a distinctive value proposition into a captivating narrative that resonates with the client’s key audiences.
When the existing Cisco.com needed to revamp its outdated content, Tendo conducted in-depth research to develop a content framework that could be expanded and maintained easily throughout the site. After evaluating the site’s current state, reviewing competitors, and interviewing key stakeholders, they created a content architecture and scalable content models, including organization, prioritization, and copy specifications for key page types.
Following this redesign, unique visitors to Cisco.com increased by 15%, task completion rose by 13%, and the click-through rate skyrocketed to 68%. Additionally, "contact us" clicks saw a remarkable 32% increase. The success was further validated through metrics, prompting Cisco to develop a design system based on Tendo’s content framework and apply it across all business units.
Notable Clients: Semrush, BigCommerce, SpyFu, Sprout Social, Influencer Marketing Hubb, and more
Attrock is a results-driven digital marketing company with an impressive track record of helping clients achieve remarkable milestones, including ranking for over 5,000 keywords on Google's first page and driving a 128% increase in leads and conversions.
It also played a vital role in scaling agencies from five to seven-figure incomes within two years by providing digital marketing services like content marketing, SEO, influencer Marketing, PR, lead Generation, and more.
Its content marketing campaign for ShaneBarker.com was aimed at increasing backlinks, building a strong social media presence, improving SERPs rankings, and boosting site traffic. By optimizing the web content and implementing SEO measures, its blog posts started to rank on the first page of Google search results without the need for link building. High-quality social media content also helped nurture its robust social media presence, with the number of sessions from LinkedIn growing from 686 to 16,000 in two years.
Notable Clients: Las Vegas Tourism, Miami Beach Pride, Midmark, BurgerFi, and more
S&G is a renowned content marketing agency consisting of experienced experts with diverse backgrounds, from prestigious newspapers, renowned magazines, Fortune 500 companies, and innovative technology firms. Its expertise has earned them recognition, making it among the top 50 global content marketing agencies by The Content Marketing Institute.
S&G collaborated with JW Aluminum to position the brand as a disruptor in the traditional metals manufacturing industry; it launched a new app to reduce lead times for procurement professionals and streamline supply chains for customers.
The firm created a comprehensive white paper exploring supply chain logistics in the metals industry and how technology could improve efficiency and boost revenue. The white paper generated over 200 new leads in only six months and served as a landing page for JWA's PR campaign, resulting in feature stories in Forbes, Supply Chain Brain, and other relevant industry publications.
Notable Clients: PayPal, NetApp, Sofinnova, and more
The Content Bureau is a fully remote, majority-female team dedicated to ensuring client success by balancing corporate marketing and branding protocols with trusted partnerships to provide maximum value over time. Its specialty is crafting B2B marketing assets, including copywriting, editing, and layout solutions for articles, banner ads, blog posts, and webinars.
The firm produced authentic and unscripted thought leadership videos for their client, SAP, to help partners and marketing staff understand the company's software business model. The challenge was to create engaging and authentic content while adhering to SAP brand guidelines.
According to the client, the collaboration between them and the agency resulted in fun, painless, and on-brand videos. It successfully delivered work quickly and professionally, reaching thousands of viewers and earning positive feedback from field sales representatives. Overall, the authenticity behind the videos proved to be a successful sales tool that effectively communicated the message to their target audience.
Notable Clients: monday.com, Freshworks, ActiveCampaign, AdEspresso, Zapier, and more
Codeless produces hundreds of long-form articles each month for some of the internet's biggest SaaS, service, and affiliate brands. Its process begins with SEO experts identifying content categories that resonate with the target market. The dedicated account managers then facilitate the production process, from keyword identification to uploading the finished product to your CMS.
The agency helped monday.com increase monthly blog traffic from 12,586 to more than 304,000 within 18 months. Despite the hyper-competitive nature of B2B and SaaS niches, Codeless helped them expand its business and secure significant clients such as Coca-Cola, Hulu, and Universal.
Its strategy involved creating content at scale to produce 950+ articles (2,000 words each). This enabled the client to rank for 140,000+ organic keywords with 25,626 first-page rankings on SERPs and amass backlinks from 6,500+ domains, adding to their traffic numbers.
How We Picked the Best Content Marketing Companies
To curate the list of the top content marketing companies, we examined the agencies’ client roster, testimonials, case studies, industry reputation, team expertise, and executive management. Our team of agency experts created a scoring system to gauge their overall performance based on metrics such as:
Relevant content marketing service catalog
Coverage of content marketing topics on their website and other channels
The number of content marketing projects delivered
The quality and diversity of portfolio, and success stories
Notable clients and well-known brands
Their online reputation on DesignRush, Google, and other platforms
This qualitative process helped us narrow down the cream of the crop content marketing providers you can work with on your upcoming project.
10 Most Popular Content Marketing Agencies Compared
Agency Name
Location
Hourly Rate
Size
Best For
HigherVisibility
Memphis, TN
Inquire
50-99
Overall
Siege Media
San Diego, CA
$100
100-249
Conversion-Focused Content
Brafton
Boston, MA
$150
100-249
SEO
Column Five Media
Orange County, CA
$145
Under 49
SaaS Companies
Single Grain
Los Angeles, CA
Inquire
Under 49
B2C Enterprises
Tendo Communications
San Francisco, CA
Inquire
Under 49
B2B Brands
Attrock
Miami, FL
$49
Under 49
Content Analysis
S&G
Miami, FL
$175
Under 49
Branded Content
The Content Bureau
Orinda, FL
Inquire
Under 49
Internal Marketing
Codeless
Lone Tree, CO
Inquire
50-99
Long-Form Content
Best Content Marketing Companies
7,100 Companies-Rankings updated: September 05, 2026
DesignRush assesses content marketing companies for their expertise and verified client experiences to help you make better decisions. Certain agencies have paid placements.
Devlixor Technologies is a high-velocity digital engineering firm dedicated to transforming complex technical challenges into market-leading growth engines. Specializing in Next.js architecture and AI-driven automation via n8n, we build scalable digital backbones for brands across the USA, UK, and APAC...
To The Mars is a full-stack social media agency that turns raw ideas into consistent, high-performing content. With a diverse client base from cafés to tech products and influencers we simplify growth by managing everything from strategy to execution...
Mail Masters SA is a story-driven email and social media marketing agency based in Pretoria, South Africa.
We build automated email systems welcome flows, abandoned carts, winbacks, browse abandonment and organic social strategies for wellness, beauty, food & beverage, and e-commerce brands. Every email we...
Moxie Digital is a B2B content studio based in India, helping SaaS founders and growth-stage brands build compounding inbound pipelines. We combine SEO, LinkedIn ghostwriting, content repurposing, and Answer Engine Optimisation (AEO) into one integrated system — so your brand ranks on Google, gets cited by...
Building Future-Ready Skills & Scalable Digital Solutions
Building Future-Ready Skills & Scalable Digital Solutions
NithishReddy is a Hyderabad-based digital specialist helping individuals and businesses grow with practical solutions in Generative AI, Prompt Engineering, Full Stack Development, and SEO. Through nithishreddy.in, he focuses on delivering real-world training and performance-driven digital services that enable...
KIRA Marketing Management is a Dubai-based growth agency that bridges the gap between creative storytelling and data-driven performance. Specializing in AI-integrated strategies, they help startups and SMEs scale through high-converting web development, multi-channel paid ads, and brand identity. By...
Al Murooj Solutions is a leading digital transformation company in Dubai. We offer top-notch digital transformation services to drive businesses into the future...
Binary Techno is a web design company in India known for delivering creative, high-quality web design services that help businesses grow and succeed online...
Outcome Digital Marketing is a Cornwall-based agency specialising in SEO, website design, blog writing, and market research. We help small businesses grow online with transparent strategies that deliver real results...
Agência Mint is a São Paulo-based digital marketing agency with 50 specialists. We help brands grow through SEO, Social Media, Digital Strategy, and Content Creation with data-driven, creative solutions...
Creative, Data-driven Marketing That Actually Grows Your Business.
Creative, Data-driven Marketing That Actually Grows Your Business.
Bubble Digital is a Brighton & Hove-based marketing agency run by Megan, helping ambitious businesses grow with clear, tailored strategies. From websites and branding to social media, email and ads, everything is designed to connect with your audience and deliver real results...
Big Ideas, Smart Strategies, And Endless Creativity
Big Ideas, Smart Strategies, And Endless Creativity
OTOPO is a creative digital agency specializing in web & app design, digital marketing, branding, and content creation. We help startups and businesses grow online through smart strategies, influencer marketing, and performance-driven campaigns. Based in Dubai and Abu Dhabi, we work globally with ambitious...
Conversion-Focused SEO & Digital Marketing For Service Businesses
Conversion-Focused SEO & Digital Marketing For Service Businesses
At Mindsphere Digitech, we help businesses move beyond traffic numbers and focus on what actually matters - leads, conversions, and revenue. As a performance-driven digital marketing agency in Ahmedabad, we build SEO and paid marketing strategies that attract the right audience and guide them toward real...
As a trusted digital marketing company in Bangalore, Entellus & Co specializes in delivering innovative strategies that help businesses expand their online reach and achieve measurable growth...
Arketi Group is an integrated B2B marketing and PR agency that helps technology companies generate revenue and accelerate growth. We combine strategy, public relations, digital marketing, branding, web, content, workplace communications, and demand generation to build visibility, strengthen market position...
Empowering Business Growth With Smart Digital & IT Solutions
Empowering Business Growth With Smart Digital & IT Solutions
Prabisha Consulting is a global IT and digital solutions company helping businesses grow through innovation and strategy. Founded in 2018, we specialise in website development, SEO, and AI-powered solutions. We are also the creators of AI Nexus World, a global AI ecosystem platform connecting professionals...
Web design and SEO agency in Braunschweig, Germany. We build high-performance websites and implement SEO strategies for local businesses. 26 five-star Google reviews...
Act Local is a Dubai-based digital marketing agency specializing in SEO, PPC, web development, branding, content creation, and social media marketing. The agency focuses on delivering data-driven strategies and measurable growth for businesses across industries such as hospitality, real estate, automotive...
Uzair Visuals is a remote branding and growth studio serving early-stage founders and growing businesses across the US, UK, Canada, and globally. We use AI-assisted tools and systems alongside our creative expertise to deliver brand identity design, website development, growth marketing, SEO, visual design...
Engineering Commercial Infrastructure For B2B Life Sciences.
Engineering Commercial Infrastructure For B2B Life Sciences.
Fractorial provides account-based marketing services tailored for the unique needs of B2B life science companies. Our approaches to find companies aligned to your ICP, deploy messaging and content that resonate with each member of the buying group, and drive business opportunities and ROI will elevate your...
Quietly is a content marketing partner focused on measurable outcomes. We design high-velocity AEO content programs that connect strategy, production, and optimization to drive visibility, performance, and scale. Trusted by brands like DoorDash, Adobe, and Pinterest, we deliver content that performs and...
Baal & Spots is a full-service digital marketing agency based in Houston, TX, that can manage everything across your marketing channels. Let us do the hard work while you focus on what matters most: running your business...
With a network of 150K+ content placement sites, Adsy enables data-driven link building, digital PR, and content distribution at scale. We focus on measurable ROI, transparency, and long-term partnerships helping our clients grow visibility and authority across competitive markets...
Since 2001, PIC has helped B2B, ecommerce, and service brands across Pennsylvania and the five contiguous states, including many right here in Pittsburgh, turn traffic into revenue. Our South Hills team delivers full-funnel growth marketing including SEO, PPC, inbound & account based campaigns, website and...
Modocon is a Brazilian boutique Public Relations and Corporate Communications agency specialized in B2B and B2C Corporate Communications, Reputation Management, and AEO & GEO...
We are in the attention business. We are a full-service advertising agency that doesn't do boring. We create attention through BIG WORK that makes a BIG IMPACT...
Ari Digital is a B2B demand generation agency helping companies in Technology, SaaS, IT Services, Education, Manufacturing, and Professional Services build a consistent, qualified pipeline. We run LinkedIn outreach, cold email, performance campaigns, and cold calling all under one unified strategy designed to...
At Proftcode, we deliver powerful software development and AI-driven solutions that help businesses innovate, automate, and scale faster. Our expertise includes custom web development, mobile app development, ERP and CRM software, and intelligent automation systems...
PACIFIK'AI is the first AI-native agency in French Polynesia. We build chatbots, automation workflows, premium websites, and AI marketing solutions for Pacific businesses...
Nodus Works helps brands grow with tailored Shopify and Shopify Plus solutions. We design and develop fast, scalable, and conversion-focused e-commerce experiences, from custom themes and UX/UI improvements to enterprise workflows powered by Checkout Extensibility, Shopify Functions, and Flow...
Advery is a full-service branding and digital strategy powerhouse where data-driven insights meet disruptive creativity. We dont just design logos; we engineer brand ecosystems that command attention and drive sustainable revenue. From market-entry strategy to high-impact visual identities, we help ambitious...
Instant Search Visibility And Scalable ROI Through Google Ads.
Instant Search Visibility And Scalable ROI Through Google Ads.
Business Cherub is a premier SEO agency in Melbourne specializing in local search, technical audits, and high-authority link building for Australian brands...
Digitize Your Dining Operations & Delight Every Guest
Digitize Your Dining Operations & Delight Every Guest
wayinfotech solutions is a forward thinking software development agency dedicated to helping businesses grow through innovvative and sccalable technology solutions. with a strong focus on client centric development , the company specializes in delivering customised services across web development...
Your Growth Partner In A Fast-moving Digital World!
Your Growth Partner In A Fast-moving Digital World!
To blend creativity and technology into every strategy we craft, helping businesses of all sizes reach global audiences efficiently and affordably. At KVN Promos, we dont just market brands we help them make their mark in the digital universe...
GrowPad is an inbound growth agency for SaaS and tech companies. We help clients become the first click when buyers search for a SaaS or IT vendor - in Google and AI-powered search. We fix cannibalization, restructure money pages, and build vertical authority through SEO, LLMO, GEO, and AEO. Results: 2×...
Strategic marketing consultancy helping SMEs grow through SEO, GEO, websites, design and conversion strategy, focused on measurable outcomes and long-term success...
We Help Nigerian Businesses Turn Website Traffic Into Paying Customers
We Help Nigerian Businesses Turn Website Traffic Into Paying Customers
Adfluent Digital Marketing Agency is a leading Digital Marketing Agency in Nigeria helping businesses grow through strategic, data-driven marketing solutions. As a trusted Digital Marketing Company in Nigeria and results-focused online marketing agency Nigeria, we serve clients across Lagos Nigeria, Abuja...
The best AI development services in India, Web Nautical helps us to delivering custom AI solutions, machine learning, automation, and data-driven products to help start ups and enterprises scale faster and smarter...
By ASN Digital (SMC-PVT) LTD is a professional digital marketing agency based in Sargodha, Pakistan, serving clients across the UK, UAE, USA and worldwide. We specialize in SEO, Local SEO, Website Development, Website Redesigning, Google Ads, PPC, and Meta Ads...
We design brand ecosystems that evolve, scale, and inspire, powered by The Pulse Principle, our three-phase methodology rooted in your brands essence. Every phase is intentional, interconnected, and built around your truth, setting you apart in ways that resonate deeply with your audience...
Lakeside Creative Labs is a Detroit-area digital marketing agency specializing in social media management, SEO, and web design for small businesses across Southeast Michigan. We use data-driven strategies and creative content to help local businesses get found online...
Hilton Software Technologies is an IT solutions company based in Hyderabad, delivering customized software, web, and digital services since 2013. The company helps businesses of all sizes accelerate growth through innovative technology, reliable support, and tailored digital solutions...
GrowthSpree is an AI-native marketing agency focused on helping B2B SaaS companies scale their pipeline through proactive demand generation. By combining senior marketing operators with proprietary AI agents, the company delivers faster execution, better lead quality, and measurable revenue outcomes...
Mauve Verse is a Chicago-based full-service digital agency that helps small businesses and startups build powerful online presences through web design, development, SEO, and digital marketing. Focused on affordability and measurable results, the agency delivers enterprise-level solutions tailored for growing...
7 Frequently Asked Questions About Content Marketing Agencies
What do content marketing companies do?
Content marketing companies create and distribute digital content intended to inform, attract, engage, retain, and inspire action across target audiences. The main goal of their produced work is to drive greater brand awareness, boost organic traffic and SEO rankings, and guide prospects through the buyer's journey to ultimately increase leads and sales.
What services do they provide?
Key services provided by content marketing agencies include:
Content strategy development: Curating bespoke plans to align content with business objectives, ideal customer profile (ICP) intent, and industry trends.
SEO copywriting and keyword research: Optimizing content to rank higher in search engine result pages (SERPs) and improve visibility to potential customers.
Editorial management and publishing: Sourcing writers, editing content, managing content calendars, and handling the publishing process.
Distribution and promotion: Making sure the content reaches the target audience through social media, email campaigns, and paid advertising.
Performance analysis: Monitoring how content performs and tracking traffic, engagement, and conversion rate metrics to refine strategies.
How much does a content marketing company cost to hire?
Across the US, a content marketing company usually charges between $100 to $500 per 1000-word post.For social media content, the price usually goes between $50 and $150 per post.
The final price can vary based on a combination of factors:
Length and topic complexity: Shorter, simpler posts cost less compared to in-depth, longer articles.
Expertise: Posts requiring niche knowledge or specific writing style entail higher fees.
SEO adjustments: Extending the service with SEO services like keyword research and integration can also raise the price.
Additional services: Content promotion, social media sharing, and visual add-ons count as an addition to the base fee.
How long do different content pieces take to write?
Short, standard articles can take an experienced writer 1 to 3 hours to write, while research-heavy pieces may require over 10 hours. Same as with pricing, the topic complexity and research requirements affect the writing time as well.
In general, seasoned writers can produce 500 words in 30 to 60 minutes, while for the same work, a beginner might need 2 to 3 hours or more.
Here are some average time estimates by content type:
Social media posts/short content (75 to 300 words): 30 minutes to an hour
Standard blog post/article (500 to 1000 words): 1 to 3 hours (assuming moderate research)
1,500-word piece: 3 to 6 hours, depending on depth
Long-form, 2,000-word content piece: 6 to 10+ hours
Technical content piece: Up to 10 hours per 500 words, given the need for extensive research and citations
Full website content coverage (20 pages): 11 to 40 days, depending on the complexity of the brand voice and required research
What types of businesses benefit most from working with a content marketing agency?
Small businesses, startups, expanding brands, and companies looking to set or correct a brand image benefit the most from a content marketing collaboration.
Businesses starting from the ground up benefit a lot from a content marketing agency as it maps out a clear strategy and builds an audience from day one. Companies dealing with a bad reputation or a complex rebranding phase also see considerable returns, as a good agency can use honest storytelling to fix misconceptions and win back trust.
At the same time, if a brand is entering a new market or launching a unique product line, specialized content helps them spread the message more easily by producing pieces in the local language.
How long does it take to see results from content marketing services?
Content marketing follows a more extended trajectory as it takes time for search engines to recognize and rank the content. As the content library expands and gains credibility, brands start to see incremental growth in 3 to 6 months.
The same goes for social media: as content compounds and reaches more people, the organic traffic gets steadier and lead generation efforts start gaining more traction.
How is content marketing different than SEO?
Content marketing is the substance, i.e., the strategy of creating value to build a relationship with the intended audience. SEO is the visibility or the technical process of making that value discoverable by search engines.
Essentially, they are two sides of the same coin: SEO makes demands (keywords, structure), and content marketing fulfills them.
Across both practices, quality comes first. Namely, if the piece is optimized for a search engine but fails against the intent of the reader, the content will eventually lose its rank because it lacks topical authority.
Proposals